Skip to content
FibonacciDentistryLog inTry it free

Consent and legal protection

Informed consent in dentistry: what to tell the patient, when to put it in writing and how to keep it in the clinical record

Informed consent in dentistry: what the Ministry of Health and Italian Law 219/2017 say on content, written form and revocation, and how to keep it on file.

The Fibonacci editorial teamUpdated on 7 min read

A dentist sitting beside a patient with a model of a set of teeth in hand, sample image.
In this article
  1. What is said at the chairside
  2. The conversation is the doctor's
  3. The Ministry in September, the law in December
  4. If the patient says no, or changes their mind
  5. Orthodontics and sedation: two cases where a single form is not enough
  6. How much patients remember
  7. The five templates and the signature on the tablet
  8. Before having it signed

Informed consent is the explanation you give the patient before you start: what you will do, which complications you expect, which alternatives exist and why some of them are not suitable for them. The signed form proves that you gave it. On the written form, the two main Italian sources do not coincide. The Ministry of Health's clinical Recommendations (September 2017) do not impose it on the self-employed professional and advise it in complex cases. Italian Law 219/2017 (opens in a new tab), from December of the same year, requires consent to be documented in writing or by video recording. If you want evidence that holds up, you keep the document.

What is said at the chairside

The Ministry (opens in a new tab) text requires you to inform about the treatment plan and the alternative options, explaining why some are not considered valid in the specific case. For risks, it is enough to set out the complications that are reasonably and concretely foreseeable: no excessive detail on facts that can only be hypothesised in the abstract. Consent, it adds, does not exempt you from liability for errors of diagnosis, of treatment or for unjustifiably risky technical choices.

Putting the Ministry, Italian Law 219/2017 (art. 1, paragraph 3) and the Code of Ethics (arts. 33 and 35) side by side, the conversation covers the plan in summary and the expected result, the risk-benefit ratio compared with alternative techniques, the alternatives themselves, the complications that are concretely foreseeable and what happens if the patient refuses treatment. The Code adds the behaviours to observe after the session. The Ministry wants the names of the clinicians to whom the consent is addressed and of any other specialists who will be involved.

The law speaks of information that is complete, up to date and understandable. The Code requires you to adapt communication to the person's capacity to understand and to answer every request for clarification. The patient may also not want to know, or may name a trusted person to receive the information in their place. The refusal and any such appointment go in the clinical record.

The conversation is the doctor's

Under article 35 of the Code of Medical Ethics (opens in a new tab), obtaining consent or dissent is an act of specific and exclusive competence of the doctor, which cannot be delegated. The Ministry takes this up again. If the assistant prepares the form and the front desk passes it round, the conversation and the obtaining of consent remain yours regardless.

With a minor, the consent of the parents or guardians is required (Ministry chapter on paediatric dentistry), and article 35 requires you to give adequate consideration to the minor's opinion.

The Ministry in September, the law in December

The Ministry writes that for those practising dentistry as a self-employed professional there is, at present, no obligation to obtain consent in writing. The written form is advisable in complex cases, those with at least one of these characteristics:

  • techniques not commonly used in dental practice
  • therapies not known to most patients or difficult to understand
  • testing of techniques or materials
  • use of biomaterials
  • treatment of minors and special patients

Three months later comes Italian Law 219/2017. Article 1, paragraph 4, says that consent, obtained in the manner most suited to the patient's condition, is documented in writing or by video recording, and that in whatever form it is expressed it goes into the clinical record. The Code, at article 35, requires the written and signed form, or other methods of equivalent documentary efficacy, in the cases provided for by the legal system and in those with a high risk of mortality or with outcomes that significantly affect psycho-physical integrity.

Which of the texts applies to a specific case of yours is a question for the practice's lawyer: the dates are different and neither source says it prevails over the other. On evidence, however, the fact is simple. An oral consent alone you prove with your word. A signed document and a note in the record remain.

If the patient says no, or changes their mind

Paragraph 5 of Italian Law 219/2017 recognises the right of every person with capacity to refuse all or part of an examination or treatment and to revoke at any time consent already given, in the forms set out in paragraph 4. The doctor respects the expressed wish (paragraph 6). The 2014 review places informed refusal on the same footing as consent: if the patient refuses a treatment that is essential in your view, their signature is still needed.

The record must be able to say what you proposed, what the patient chose and when.

Orthodontics and sedation: two cases where a single form is not enough

These are proposals by groups of authors, not Italian rules.

A 2025 consensus, built with the Delphi method by the Chinese orthodontic society, describes consent in three stages: initial consultation, treatment, retention. It requires you to explain the plan, risks, uncertainties and costs, and to keep communication open throughout the care. Consent accompanies the treatment, it does not end at the first session.

For sedation, a 2026 review of eight studies (from 1988 to 2023) proposes a separate consent, distinct from that for the dental procedure. It includes the indication, the alternatives, the technique with the drugs envisaged and the route of administration, monitoring, risks and benefits, and the recommendations after the session. It requires the verbal explanation alongside the written one and verification that the patient has understood. For those who wish, the form is taken home and returned signed on the day of the procedure: this shows that they had time to decide calmly.

How much patients remember

A 2026 online survey among patients in Saudi Arabia collected 585 people with dental care behind them (25% response rate). For the majority, they say they were rarely or never informed of the specific risks of extraction: 92% for tooth fracture, 91% for temporary nerve damage. These are patients' recollections in another country, not a record of what the dentist said. They nevertheless show that information given only verbally leaves little trace.

The five templates and the signature on the tablet

The consent library has the Dentistry category with five templates: extraction, implantology, orthodontics, endodontics, whitening. These are fixed starting texts, to be reviewed by you and the practice's lawyer before use. The software does not write the consent in your place. For the ready-made templates, before saving, it has you re-read the text section by section and adopt it as your own. The risks and alternatives for the individual patient remain your choice.

The signature is done on the tablet in the practice, and the consent goes into the record along with the rest. A signed consent cannot be modified: if the plan changes, a new one is prepared. For revocation there is an item in the consent menu: the status changes to Revoked and the original document remains in the archive. The functions are on the consents page.

Consent to the processing of data is another matter, and for treatment it is not required: it is discussed in health data in the dental practice.

Before having it signed

  • Plan in summary and expected result
  • Alternatives, consequences of refusal, reason why some are ruled out for this patient
  • Complications that are concretely foreseeable, without every possible scenario
  • Who will carry out the treatment and the other specialists involved
  • What to do and not do after the session
  • Patient's questions, answers given, understanding verified
  • Complex case (uncommon technique, biomaterials, minor, special patient): written form
  • Minor: parents or guardians sign, the minor is heard
  • Refusal of information or appointment of a trusted person: written in the record
  • Plan changed: new consent
  • Document in the record, with date and signature

Sources

  1. Italian Ministry of Health, Clinical recommendations in odontostomatology, September 2017 (opens in a new tab)
  2. Italian Law 22 December 2017, no. 219, art. 1 (Normattiva) (opens in a new tab)
  3. FNOMCeO Code of Medical Ethics, arts. 33 and 35 (2014 text with updates) (opens in a new tab)
  4. Consensus on informed consent for orthodontic treatment, 2025, PMID 41309117 (opens in a new tab)
  5. Procedural sedation in dentistry: a scoping review and proposal for an ad hoc informed consent, 2026, PMC12990647 (opens in a new tab)
  6. Patient-reported gaps in use and quality of informed consent practices in dental care in Saudi Arabia, 2026, PMC13237990 (opens in a new tab)
  7. What's the deal with dental records for practicing dentists, 2014, PMC3970394 (opens in a new tab)

These articles explain what regulations and guidelines require and what is documented in the medical record. They are not legal or tax advice on your situation and do not say how to treat a patient.

Try Fibonacci in your practice for 15 days, no credit card needed

Within one working day we call you: together we set up your practice and import your data.

Try it free

Read next

All articles